Fourth Circuit backs Maryland against Kalshi, judges split
The split leaves the Fourth, Sixth & Ninth Circuits disagreeing on why state law beats Kalshi, while the Third Circuit went the other way.
The hit
The Fourth Circuit ruled against Kalshi, siding with Maryland, but the two judges in the majority disagreed on why, according to InGame. Judge Roger Gregory said federal law does not override state gambling rules; Judge Stephanie Thacker said sports contracts are not swaps at all.
Why it matters
The legal fight over sports event contracts is nowhere near settled. A Kalshi spokesperson said the judges have no unified, coherent legal argument against prediction markets. InGame reports the splintered ruling may highlight the need for the Supreme Court to settle the matter.
The record
| Ruling | Fourth Circuit affirmed Maryland district court, 2-1 (Tuesday) |
|---|---|
| First federal court to back a state | U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland, August 2025 |
| Dissent | Judge DeAndra Gist Benjamin says CEA preempts state law & contracts are swaps, but that parlays & prop bets are not swaps |
| Rival rulings | Third Circuit backed Kalshi 2-1; Sixth Circuit found state gambling laws preempted & sports contracts not swaps; Ninth Circuit backed states on swaps only |
What happens next
Kalshi could ask for an en banc hearing or appeal to the Supreme Court, according to InGame.
Sources: Fourth Circuit Sides With Maryland Over Kalshi
Named in this story? Reply to newsdesk@infobets.com & we publish it.
18+. Betting involves risk. If gambling is a problem for you or someone close to you, help is available.
Work with BH Group. Paid ads that get iGaming & crypto brands players & users, in the GEOs you choose. Get a plan



Discussion
Ask a question, add useful context or share a source. Keep it relevant & respectful.
Add a comment
Comments are reviewed before publication.